Takehome

COBRA vs marketplace after a job loss: which health cover costs less

COBRA continues the employer plan at full cost for a limited time. The ACA marketplace may subsidize a new plan. Compare both quotes before the election window closes.

When employer coverage ends, people ask how to keep health insurance without a spike. COBRA continues the same plan; you pay the full premium plus a small admin fee. The ACA marketplace can offer a different plan with income-based subsidies after a loss of coverage. Compare both before the COBRA election deadline. Property and cars do not enter US premiums the way some other systems do — income and plan design do.

Employer plan versus marketplace quote

What COBRA actually is

Qualifying events include job loss, reduced hours, and certain family events. Coverage length is often 18 months for job-based events, longer in some cases. You usually have 60 days to elect after the notice. Miss the window and COBRA is closed for that event. Paying late can terminate coverage.

The premium is the full employer-rate cost, not the employee-only share you saw on the stub. That is why COBRA feels like two or three times the old paycheck deduction. Run the monthly COBRA quote next to a marketplace quote for the same household size.

COBRA election window

Marketplace subsidies

A loss of employer coverage is a qualifying life event for a special enrollment period. Premium tax credits depend on expected household income and the cost of the benchmark plan in your area. Healthcare.gov or your state exchange runs the estimate. Gig income and unemployment benefits count. Underestimating income can mean repaying credit at tax time.

Subsidy estimate sketch

Dependents

Spouses and children on the old plan need their own election decisions. Sometimes one adult takes COBRA for continuity with a specialist, while others move to marketplace plans. Two COBRA premiums can exceed one family marketplace plan — price both.

Dependents on the same election

Networks matter more than the logo

Keeping COBRA keeps the same doctors if they stay in network. A cheaper marketplace plan that drops your oncologist is not cheaper in real life. Download both provider directories before you elect.

Networks and deductibles

If you take a new job

New employer coverage usually ends the need for COBRA going forward. Timing gaps of even a month can leave you exposed. Align the new start date with the old end date. Short contract work without benefits sends you back to marketplace or spouse coverage.

New job ends the gap

Severance that includes a few months of employer-paid premiums is not the same as COBRA you pay yourself. Read the separation agreement. Use the paycheck calculator only for wage leftovers, not for premium math.

Deductibles and out-of-pocket max

A lower COBRA premium with a high deductible can still lose to a marketplace silver plan with cost-sharing reductions if your income qualifies. Price the deductible, copays, and out-of-pocket maximum for a realistic year — one surgery, not a perfect healthy year. Prescription formularies differ even when the carrier logo looks familiar.

HSA eligibility ends when you enroll in a non-HDHP. Moving from an HSA-eligible employer plan to a typical COBRA PPO can freeze new HSA contributions. Existing HSA cash can still pay qualified expenses. Confirm HDHP status on both quotes before you assume the HSA keeps filling.

Short bridges and travel

If a new job starts in six weeks, a short COBRA election (you can often drop later) can bridge specialists mid-treatment. Marketplace plans have their own effective dates. Do not assume next-day coverage. Traveling abroad during the gap does not pause US enrollment clocks. Set calendar reminders for premium due dates; a missed COBRA payment can terminate coverage with limited cure rights.

Where to enroll

Plan administrator COBRA notice, Healthcare.gov or your state exchange, and the Summary of Benefits. This page is a 2026 planning sketch. The election forms win. Keep PDF copies of both quotes and the COBRA election confirmation. If a subsidy reconciliation on Form 8962 looks wrong next April, those PDFs shorten the call.

Where to enroll

Next: Paycheck calculator