Takehome

Cash out severance and you may owe more — 401(k) or IRA rollover order

A lump-sum severance check can raise withholding and your year-end bill. A direct rollover into a 401(k) or IRA keeps pretax dollars in a retirement account.

Severance is usually wages. Take it as a taxable lump sum and payroll withholds; your final tax is settled on the return. Move eligible retirement money with a direct rollover into a 401(k) or IRA and pretax dollars can stay deferred. If you are in your 50s and do not need the cash on a fixed date, price the rollover path first. This page orders the steps, the tax on a cash-out, and what changes after 59½.

Lump-sum severance versus a rollover

What a cash severance check does on day one

Employers often treat severance as supplemental wages. Federal withholding may use a flat method or the aggregate method under IRS Publication 15. Social Security and Medicare still apply while you are under the wage base. State withholding depends on where you work and live. The amount on the stub is not your final tax. A large check in one year can push more income into higher brackets even if the marginal rate only applies to the top slice.

Vacation payouts and bonuses stacked in the same month make the stub look worse. Ask payroll whether the severance will be coded as wages and whether they will withhold at the supplemental rate. Confirm before your last day. The W-2 at year end wins over a forum post.

The same dollars, two ways

Say pretax severance is $80,000 and withholding on a lump sum is roughly $20,000. Your account shows about $60,000. A direct rollover of eligible plan money into an IRA or a new employer 401(k) moves the pretax balance without a current distribution if the paperwork is done as a trustee-to-trustee transfer. Cash that is pure severance wages cannot always ride that path — plan documents and the separation agreement decide what is “eligible rollover distribution.” Read the 402(f) notice the plan must give you.

Pretax dollars staying deferred
Withdrawals after 59½

Direct rollover order

  1. Before you leave, open a traditional IRA in your name at a broker or bank if you do not already have one, or confirm the new employer’s 401(k) accepts incoming rollovers. Compare fees and investment menus.
  2. Ask HR or the plan administrator for a direct rollover to that account. A check payable to you is an indirect rollover with a 60-day clock and mandatory withholding on eligible amounts. Miss the clock and the distribution is taxable.
  3. After the credit posts, do not spend rolled principal as if it were this year’s new contribution. Contribution limits and the rollover are different boxes on Form 5498 and the 1040.
Opening an IRA before the last day
Giving payroll the rollover account details

If you already have a 401(k) at the old job, you can often leave it, roll to an IRA, or roll to a new 401(k). Leaving it is fine if fees are low and you like the funds. Rolling to an IRA usually opens more ETF choices. Rolling to a new 401(k) can help if you want a loan feature later. None of those choices is automatic — you file forms.

Roth vs traditional

A Roth conversion of pretax severance-related plan money is a taxable event in the year of conversion. Do not convert just because a blog said Roth is always better. Run the tax in a high-income exit year versus a lower-income year. This site’s paycheck calculator prices a salary, not a conversion. A CPA prices the conversion.

New contributions are a different pile

Employee 401(k) deferrals and IRA contributions for the year have IRS dollar caps. A rollover does not use those caps. Mixing “I rolled $80,000 so I already maxed the IRA” is wrong. You can still contribute up to the annual IRA limit if you have earned income and meet income tests for a deduction or Roth eligibility.

New contributions versus rolled principal

Break it early and penalties stack

Withdraw pretax retirement money before 59½ and you often owe income tax plus a 10% additional tax unless an exception applies (substantially equal payments, disability, and other IRC §72(t) exceptions). Severance cash that never entered a plan is just wages — no 10% plan penalty, but full ordinary income. If you need house money in two weeks, a rollover may be the wrong tool. If the need is six months out, roll first and then look at a loan or a planned withdrawal with advice.

Early withdrawal penalty risk

Job changes more than once

Cash every exit and you restart without the compounding of pretax balances. Park each eligible rollover in one IRA and the old balances stay invested. Unemployment benefits are a separate state decision. How you take severance wages does not decide UI eligibility.

What to tell HR

If payroll asks whether to send everything to your checking account, you already need the rollover instructions written down. Some employers default to a cash check. “I’ll roll it myself after it hits my account” starts the 60-day clock and withholding. Prefer a direct rollover wire or a check payable to the custodian FBO you.

Match the Form 1099-R boxes to what you expected. Code G usually marks a direct rollover. A taxable distribution code means the year will show income. Fix paperwork the same season, not three Aprils later.

Where to check

IRS Publication 575 (pension and annuity income), Publication 590-A/B (IRAs), and your plan’s summary plan description. Numbers here are planning estimates for 2026. The plan administrator and your return win. If the amount needs a tax professional, do not treat this page as the decision.

Check take-home before you choose

For a rough sense of leftover wages after federal and FICA, open the paycheck calculator. It will not price a rollover. It will show why a fat wage year feels different from a deferred balance.

Next: Paycheck calculator